Neuropsychological Associates

Neuropsychological Associates, A Psychological Services Corporation

You are here:

Home /



Get up to date information and news from Neuropsychological Associates.

Neurocognitive Tests for Concussion: Wave of the Past?

Michael Fraga - Monday, January 16, 2017

A group of Mayo Clinic researchers argued in a new review that sports concussions -- at least in ice hockey -- can be diagnosed more accurately with objective tests, such as encephalography and the King-Devick eye test, than with the neurocognitive exams favored by many leagues at all levels of play. The researchers, including USA Hockey medical director Michael Stuart, MD, examined current and emerging methods of diagnosing concussions in ice hockey in the Clinical Journal of Sports Medicine.   If they are correct, they may have an answer to the underreporting problem long plaguing sports concussion diagnosis and treatment. "Most currently used diagnostic tests are imprecise, require athlete cooperation, and are vulnerable to player and evaluator bias," wrote the authors, led by Aynsely Smith, RN, PhD. "As objective diagnostic tools become available, the diagnosis will be less vulnerable to subjective overlay of overly aggressive athletes and assertive coaches" who often try to hide the athletes' concussion-like symptoms.

Those tools -- the King-Devick test, quantified electroencephalography and blood analysis -- are available to researchers and many find them promising. "The paper is theoretical but the data coming out is fabulous," Smith told MedPage Today. She said objective tests "are going to be giving us the information we need to know not only if there's a concussion, but the severity of it."
Smith and colleagues indicated that such tests are preferable to neurocognitive tests such as the Sport Concussion Assessment Tool (SCAT) and ImPACT test, which the National Hockey League advises team physicians to use as part of its concussion protocol. (The league last year announced it would also pilot the King-Devick with 12 of its 30 teams, according to a Chicago Tribune report). Besides the NHL, most other pro, college and high school teams also favor the established tests.
"A lot of them have put their careers on the line on these things," Smith said. "Is it going to be an uphill battle? Yes ... It won't be very popular with a lot of people right away."

In their paper, Smith and colleagues wrote, "The lack of objective measures for diagnosis of concussion and serial quantitative measures of recovery compromise the identification and assessment of prospective therapies." Said Smith: "I think they've been all we had and people worked hard to make sure they're valid. The trouble is... they're still subjective. "The ones we're using, you can't manipulate data," she added. "It's like in the emergency room: I can't fake a heart attack but I can tell you I'm not having any pain if my daughter is getting married in two hours."

While Smith's team and others continue their research, they advised clinicians to use diagnostic tests "with the greatest objectivity, availability, and affordability." That means eschewing the older tests whenever possible. Clinicians working in hockey settings specifically should look for risk factors, including: history of previous concussions, head contact exposures along with the frequency to known accelerations at over 80% probability, and playing the forward position in ice hockey.
Other members of Smith's team include David Dodick, MD, who directs Mayo Clinic's concussion program, and William Roberts, MD, former president of the American College of Sports Medicine. Stuart's son Mark is an NHL defenseman.

The NHL did not immediately answer questions Friday afternoon. 
by Ryan Basen  Staff Writer, MedPage TodayJanuary 14, 2017

The USA Hockey Foundation funded part of the study.

The authors did not report conflicts of interest.

PTSD - When it comes home

Kelly Swanson - Thursday, December 31, 2015

Life doesn't begin till you come home. Many men and women struggle with the aftermath of a traumatic event. 

Most people think that Post Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD) only happens to soldiers coming home from war, but they would be very wrong. PTSD affects many people in all walks of life in various levels and intensities. Research has found that stockbrokers, CEO's, nurses, doctors, and law enforcement suffer right along side our men and women from the armed services. With so much media attention being paid to the suffering of war, prisoners are more likely to suffer PTSD as well making recovery and rehabilitation from crimes committed just that much harder to solve when they want to seek help for addiction, abuse, or remorse. 

Welcome to our blog

Kelly Swanson - Thursday, December 31, 2015
Welcome to our new blog. We will provide lots of information, tips, and important items of interest to many patients or physicians seeking education from a neurological perspective. 

When children need assessments its usually upon request from a teacher, doctor, or concerned parent. We see many children that tend to be missing some sort of curricular item that has caused a child to stand out academically. When this happens it affects the child's ability to deal with everyday sorts of events. Children are very keen to their surroundings and this awareness can sometimes out surprise parent who think their child doesn't notice obvious situations that we adults take for granted. 

Contact us

Phone: (707) 526-5424


Fax:  707-526-5900


Email Us


Find us

Copyright © Neuropsychological Associates, A Psychological Services Corporation, 2016, All rights reserved.